Search
Latest topics
» Soaking Seeds for Better Germinationby OhioGardener Today at 9:21 am
» Should I buy this compost tumbler??
by OhioGardener Today at 8:56 am
» Phosphate
by bigtoad Today at 8:35 am
» Organic compost without peat in Alberta
by OhioGardener Today at 8:05 am
» Garden Tools
by sanderson Today at 3:54 am
» worms and compost tumbler
by Soose Yesterday at 11:46 pm
» trying to Think Spring in cold Chicago
by sanderson Yesterday at 4:43 pm
» New Lifetime Compost Tumbler..
by sanderson Yesterday at 4:41 pm
» What are you eating from your garden today?
by OhioGardener Yesterday at 10:44 am
» Aero Garden for starting seeds?
by OhioGardener Yesterday at 8:23 am
» Starbucks for coffee grounds!
by sanderson 1/30/2023, 1:37 am
» N&C Midwest: January & February 2023
by OhioGardener 1/29/2023, 7:33 pm
» Placing Box on Cement
by OhioGardener 1/29/2023, 2:57 pm
» How I compost using a Tumbler
by Soose 1/29/2023, 2:45 pm
» Garlic Chives in SFG?
by OhioGardener 1/29/2023, 8:56 am
» Microgreens Gardening
by sanderson 1/28/2023, 11:42 pm
» How do I source Mels Mix for 190 cu ft????
by sanderson 1/28/2023, 11:35 pm
» Johnson Su composting Bioreactor instructions for home, not the farm.
by has55 1/28/2023, 10:57 am
» homemade vermicomposting/Worm Casting Compost Sifters
by has55 1/28/2023, 10:45 am
» Famous Gardening Quotes
by OhioGardener 1/28/2023, 8:29 am
» The SFG Journey-Johnson Su Bioreactor for composting, No turning
by has55 1/28/2023, 12:09 am
» seed starting Mel's way
by plantoid 1/27/2023, 7:09 am
» Home Made Compost
by plantoid 1/27/2023, 6:18 am
» Kiwi's SFG Adventure
by KiwiSFGnewbie 1/27/2023, 2:46 am
» Back In The Saddle I Suppose
by Scorpio Rising 1/26/2023, 8:03 pm
» New but Old
by lovey 1/25/2023, 1:49 am
» Dani's Brand New SFG For 2023
by danieggert 1/24/2023, 6:24 pm
» Seed Exchange - January 2023
by sanderson 1/24/2023, 4:43 am
» Chicken Poop compost
by OhioGardener 1/22/2023, 5:28 pm
» Holy snow Batman!
by OhioGardener 1/22/2023, 10:27 am
Google
Rock wool instead of vermiculite?
4 posters
Rock wool instead of vermiculite?
Hello.
This is my first post here, I am a newbie.
Merry Christmas to all and greetings from Bulgaria!
I am planning to start my first SFG soon but I have difficulties finding vermiculite on our market. They sell it small bags at crazy prices - 10 times more expensive than in US!
My question to you is - can I use Rock Wool instead of Vermiculite?
I can find Rock Wool in granules here, in big bags. It is successfully used in hydroponics, as far as I know. Rock Wool pH is alkaline, close to vermiculite, holds water very well, drains well.
What do you think?
This is my first post here, I am a newbie.
Merry Christmas to all and greetings from Bulgaria!
I am planning to start my first SFG soon but I have difficulties finding vermiculite on our market. They sell it small bags at crazy prices - 10 times more expensive than in US!
My question to you is - can I use Rock Wool instead of Vermiculite?
I can find Rock Wool in granules here, in big bags. It is successfully used in hydroponics, as far as I know. Rock Wool pH is alkaline, close to vermiculite, holds water very well, drains well.
What do you think?
viktorio-
Posts : 7
Join date : 2010-12-26
Location : Bulgaria, zone 6
Re: Rock wool instead of vermiculite?
Hello, Viktorio, and welcome to our forum!
I'm not familiar with rock wool in granules, but if it's all you say it is (and is used in hydroponics) then it should work well for you. The purpose of the vermiculite is to keep the mix light and fluffy and to help hold water...so if the rock wool does the same (and is safe to use in gardens) then it will do the same job.
I'm LaFee, and I'm waiting for the snow to melt here in France, but I think I'm going to be waiting a long time this winter!
Please feel free to ask anything -- there are lots of friendly people here with lots of knowledge to share.
I'm not familiar with rock wool in granules, but if it's all you say it is (and is used in hydroponics) then it should work well for you. The purpose of the vermiculite is to keep the mix light and fluffy and to help hold water...so if the rock wool does the same (and is safe to use in gardens) then it will do the same job.
I'm LaFee, and I'm waiting for the snow to melt here in France, but I think I'm going to be waiting a long time this winter!
Please feel free to ask anything -- there are lots of friendly people here with lots of knowledge to share.
LaFee-
Posts : 1023
Join date : 2010-03-03
Location : West Central Florida
Re: Rock wool instead of vermiculite?
Hello, Lafee.
Thanks for your reply.
The rock wool seems light enough - in density it varies between 50-120 kg/m3 usually. Coarse vermiculite varies between 60-80 kg/m3, so I guess those granules should be OK.
Holds water up to 10 times its weight, vermiculite holds up to 5 times its weight, so that should also be OK, I think.
Rockwool is free of pathogens, so should be safe in that regard.
I also found that rockwool absorbs phosphorus which then it releases to plants, so this seems to be beneficial.
Maybe I can try it, due to the difficulties in obtaining vermiculite.
Will be interesting to have other comments too. Thanks for your help.
Thanks for your reply.
The rock wool seems light enough - in density it varies between 50-120 kg/m3 usually. Coarse vermiculite varies between 60-80 kg/m3, so I guess those granules should be OK.
Holds water up to 10 times its weight, vermiculite holds up to 5 times its weight, so that should also be OK, I think.
Rockwool is free of pathogens, so should be safe in that regard.
I also found that rockwool absorbs phosphorus which then it releases to plants, so this seems to be beneficial.
Maybe I can try it, due to the difficulties in obtaining vermiculite.
Will be interesting to have other comments too. Thanks for your help.
viktorio-
Posts : 7
Join date : 2010-12-26
Location : Bulgaria, zone 6
Re: Rock wool instead of vermiculite?
Welcome to the forum!
Keep in mind, Viktorio, that Mel recommends just using more compost in the mix if you can't get either the peat or the vermiculite (2/3 compost and 1/3 whichever you can get). He even recommends straight compost where the other components are too expensive or otherwise not available.
I have no experience with rockwool other than having received a few plants that were grown in it, but I found it kind of difficult to deal with. BUT, this was not the granular form, it was the "wool" form. Other than that, I have no wisdom for you, sorry.
Hope you can get it sorted out and happy gardening.
Sharon
Keep in mind, Viktorio, that Mel recommends just using more compost in the mix if you can't get either the peat or the vermiculite (2/3 compost and 1/3 whichever you can get). He even recommends straight compost where the other components are too expensive or otherwise not available.
I have no experience with rockwool other than having received a few plants that were grown in it, but I found it kind of difficult to deal with. BUT, this was not the granular form, it was the "wool" form. Other than that, I have no wisdom for you, sorry.

Sharon
Odd Duck-
Posts : 327
Join date : 2010-03-08
Age : 60
Location : DFW, TX, Zone 7b/8a
Re: Rock wool instead of vermiculite?
Thanks, Sharon.
Yes, I am familiar with Mel's recommendation about using more compost instead of the missing component. But as I was looking for another vermiculite alternative I stumbled upon rock wool in hydroponics and found it has similar properties to vermiculite, at least it seems so. That's why I thought maybe somebody has experience with rock wool granules.
I will try to sort it out, sure, I will try with 1 box with rock wool and another - with 2/3 compost. Will see what happens.
Yes, I am familiar with Mel's recommendation about using more compost instead of the missing component. But as I was looking for another vermiculite alternative I stumbled upon rock wool in hydroponics and found it has similar properties to vermiculite, at least it seems so. That's why I thought maybe somebody has experience with rock wool granules.
I will try to sort it out, sure, I will try with 1 box with rock wool and another - with 2/3 compost. Will see what happens.

viktorio-
Posts : 7
Join date : 2010-12-26
Location : Bulgaria, zone 6
Welcome
Welcome, Viktorio.
It's always great to hear from European gardeners.
I have read that vermiculite also absorbs phosphorus and then releases it slowly. I looked up rockwool on the 'net and found this interesting article:
What is rockwool?
It says it was developed in Denmark in the 1970s and is made from heated basalt rock and chalk. It is used as a substitute for perlite, and it will not break down during heavy mixing as perlite or vermiculite will. It is completely inert, so it sounds as though it should work very well in your mix. Keep us posted on the results, please.
I wonder if Mel has experimented with it?
It's always great to hear from European gardeners.
I have read that vermiculite also absorbs phosphorus and then releases it slowly. I looked up rockwool on the 'net and found this interesting article:
What is rockwool?
It says it was developed in Denmark in the 1970s and is made from heated basalt rock and chalk. It is used as a substitute for perlite, and it will not break down during heavy mixing as perlite or vermiculite will. It is completely inert, so it sounds as though it should work very well in your mix. Keep us posted on the results, please.
I wonder if Mel has experimented with it?
ander217-
Posts : 1450
Join date : 2010-03-16
Age : 67
Location : Southeastern Missouri (6b)
Rockwool prices
I checked out the prices at that site. A 45-lb. 3.5 cu. ft. compressed bale is $57.40. (I'm not sure how much that would make when decompressed.)
How does that compare with your prices?
(According to an online currency converter, if I did it correctly $57.40 = 43.70 euros)
Here we can pick up coarse vermiculite for around $25-$30 for 4 cu. ft. So the rockwool would have to double in bulk when decompressed to make it competitive for us. One ad said it outlasts vermiculite by many years, however.
How does that compare with your prices?
(According to an online currency converter, if I did it correctly $57.40 = 43.70 euros)
Here we can pick up coarse vermiculite for around $25-$30 for 4 cu. ft. So the rockwool would have to double in bulk when decompressed to make it competitive for us. One ad said it outlasts vermiculite by many years, however.
ander217-
Posts : 1450
Join date : 2010-03-16
Age : 67
Location : Southeastern Missouri (6b)
Re: Rock wool instead of vermiculite?
Thank you, Ander217.
Here you can find vermiculite at crazy prices.
(Take a seat, please).
4 cu. ft. bag costs here 250.30 USD, at the current exchange rate.
There's no way I will buy it
Rockwool with density 100 kgs/m3 costs 111 USD/m3, which means 12.54 USD per 4 cu.ft. (113 liters), that's fine.
Here you can find vermiculite at crazy prices.
(Take a seat, please).
4 cu. ft. bag costs here 250.30 USD, at the current exchange rate.

There's no way I will buy it

Rockwool with density 100 kgs/m3 costs 111 USD/m3, which means 12.54 USD per 4 cu.ft. (113 liters), that's fine.
viktorio-
Posts : 7
Join date : 2010-12-26
Location : Bulgaria, zone 6
Re: Rock wool instead of vermiculite?
It looks like Vermiculite is not popular in my country so prices are too high, unlike Rock wool, where prices are cheaper.
I have no idea if Mel has experimented with Rock wool. I did not find any reference to rock wool in his books. Maybe I should ask him?
I have no idea if Mel has experimented with Rock wool. I did not find any reference to rock wool in his books. Maybe I should ask him?
viktorio-
Posts : 7
Join date : 2010-12-26
Location : Bulgaria, zone 6
Re: Rock wool instead of vermiculite?
Viktorio, I don't know if this helps or not, but I (and the people in England) have found our vermiculite at the building stores, where they sell insulation. I paid about 12 Euros for a 100-litre bag of vermiculite last spring (and am hoping the price is about the same this year, as I'm building a new box!)
If I buy it in the garden department, it's about 8 euros for a 5-litre bag...a huge difference, and a big reward for walking to the other side of the store!
I don't know if they use vermiculite for insulation in Bulgaria, but it might be worth looking, if you haven't already.
If I buy it in the garden department, it's about 8 euros for a 5-litre bag...a huge difference, and a big reward for walking to the other side of the store!
I don't know if they use vermiculite for insulation in Bulgaria, but it might be worth looking, if you haven't already.
LaFee-
Posts : 1023
Join date : 2010-03-03
Location : West Central Florida
Re: Rock wool instead of vermiculite?
LaFee, I checked some of the sellers here, but price is still too high.
Vermiculite is not popular for insulation here. Neither is rock wool, but it is still cheaper.
My last hope is asking the only vermiculite producer here, but I am not sure if he will sell small quantities. Anyway, the fight goes on. I will not give up easily
If anybody has had experience with rock wool as an alternative - I will appreciate further comments.
Vermiculite is not popular for insulation here. Neither is rock wool, but it is still cheaper.
My last hope is asking the only vermiculite producer here, but I am not sure if he will sell small quantities. Anyway, the fight goes on. I will not give up easily

If anybody has had experience with rock wool as an alternative - I will appreciate further comments.
viktorio-
Posts : 7
Join date : 2010-12-26
Location : Bulgaria, zone 6
Re: Rock wool instead of vermiculite?
I'm not sure I'd worry about it...if it's being used for hydroponics, you know there are no toxins in it, and it's in your budget, it's less work to just use the rock wool!
Mel says in his book that he doesn't use perlite because it makes him sneeze...no other reason...
Mel says in his book that he doesn't use perlite because it makes him sneeze...no other reason...
LaFee-
Posts : 1023
Join date : 2010-03-03
Location : West Central Florida
Re: Rock wool instead of vermiculite?
Yes, I will give it a try.
Thanks, LaFee.
Thanks, LaFee.
viktorio-
Posts : 7
Join date : 2010-12-26
Location : Bulgaria, zone 6

» What's in your compost pile?
» Displaying local temps at end of my posts
» Tell me what you know about Rock Dust
» Senseless Banter...
» How Many Square Feet Do You Have?
» Displaying local temps at end of my posts
» Tell me what you know about Rock Dust
» Senseless Banter...
» How Many Square Feet Do You Have?
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|