Search
Latest topics
» need specific advice on MMby danieggert Today at 10:02 am
» Senseless Banter...
by OhioGardener Yesterday at 8:11 pm
» After harvest, leave the roots in or remove
by Mikesgardn Yesterday at 7:53 pm
» Greenhouse - Helpful Hints in Setting up a Wood-Framed Greenhouse
by Scorpio Rising Yesterday at 7:46 pm
» Sifted Peat
by danieggert Yesterday at 4:21 pm
» Best choice of pot to plant my seedling
by markqz Yesterday at 1:30 pm
» Responding to a specific post
by OhioGardener Yesterday at 9:55 am
» N&C Midwest: March & April 2023
by Scorpio Rising 3/21/2023, 10:17 pm
» Kiwi's SFG Adventure
by sanderson 3/21/2023, 9:00 pm
» Think Spring 2023
by MrBooker 3/20/2023, 7:59 am
» Sifting Compost for Newbies
by sanderson 3/20/2023, 3:47 am
» Too cold to put my new MM into my raised beds?? and Facebook SFG site
by sanderson 3/20/2023, 3:39 am
» Harvesting small amounts from iceberg lettuce, caulliflower, broccoli, cabbage etc.
by sanderson 3/20/2023, 3:37 am
» Indoor seed starting question
by sanderson 3/20/2023, 3:19 am
» Epsom salts for your veggie garden??
by sanderson 3/19/2023, 11:37 pm
» seed starting Mel's way
by bigtoad 3/17/2023, 9:26 pm
» shop lights vs grow lights
by sanderson 3/17/2023, 1:53 am
» trellis netting square size
by sanderson 3/16/2023, 10:45 pm
» Ohio Gardener's Greenhouse
by OhioGardener 3/16/2023, 5:20 pm
» Sour Dough Starter
by Jjean59 3/16/2023, 2:24 pm
» Raised Beds from 48" Culvert
by wargarden2017 3/16/2023, 11:19 am
» Baby Pools as Beds?!
by Jjean59 3/15/2023, 3:54 pm
» March: What to plant in Northern California and Central Valley areas
by sanderson 3/15/2023, 3:52 pm
» So. California & Inland Valleys -March / April Planting Guide
by sanderson 3/15/2023, 2:22 pm
» Biosolids / Humanure Compost?
by OhioGardener 3/14/2023, 1:45 pm
» Hello Form the Bitterroot Valley of Montana
by sanderson 3/14/2023, 4:52 am
» Renewing Mel's Mix
by anne 3/13/2023, 8:16 pm
» help refuting a raised bed critic
by sanderson 3/13/2023, 2:26 pm
» Associations of time spent gardening with mental wellbeing and life satisfaction in Mid-to-late adulthood
by OhioGardener 3/13/2023, 9:04 am
» Hello from the north end of the Bitterroot Valley, Montana
by sanderson 3/13/2023, 5:05 am
Google
help refuting a raised bed critic
5 posters
Page 1 of 1
help refuting a raised bed critic
help refuting a raised bed critic
here is a quote from a square foot and raised bed critic
alf :
For effect, a ‘newbie’ will construct beds of uniform size but, after the first year, will find that, for example, potatoes will require vastly more space than onions, and brassicas more than carrots, with the result that fitting crops to beds becomes a problem. On the other hand, by leaving the plot ‘open’, each planting can follow on from its neighbor with just a narrow walkway left in between. Walkways themselves will also move across the plot, in line with the sowing pattern, which means that all parts of the plot (and the nutrients they contain) will be used over time. Conversely, paths between raised beds will never be used and will be inevitably wider, if only to permit the passage of a wheelbarrow, something that wouldn’t happen in ‘open’ format where barrows will be left at the sides of the plot without undue inconvenience.
here is a quote from a square foot and raised bed critic
alf :
For effect, a ‘newbie’ will construct beds of uniform size but, after the first year, will find that, for example, potatoes will require vastly more space than onions, and brassicas more than carrots, with the result that fitting crops to beds becomes a problem. On the other hand, by leaving the plot ‘open’, each planting can follow on from its neighbor with just a narrow walkway left in between. Walkways themselves will also move across the plot, in line with the sowing pattern, which means that all parts of the plot (and the nutrients they contain) will be used over time. Conversely, paths between raised beds will never be used and will be inevitably wider, if only to permit the passage of a wheelbarrow, something that wouldn’t happen in ‘open’ format where barrows will be left at the sides of the plot without undue inconvenience.
wargarden2017- Posts : 33
Join date : 2022-09-16
Location : usa
Re: help refuting a raised bed critic
No need to refute, to each their own. If the person doesn't want to use raised beds, that is their choice. There is no mandate to use raised beds, nor is there one to use SFG techniques.
Never plant without a bucket of compost at your side.
sanderson likes this post
Re: help refuting a raised bed critic
It's unclear what sort of comparison is being made. I'm guessing a row garden? The advantage (well, one of the advantages) of raised beds the SFG way, and separate walkways, is that you don't have to turn and till your soil every year (or every half year). This is a real time and back saver. It also makes it much easier to do weeding, since any weeds are not deeply ensconced in soil.
The assumption that you're missing out by not rotating over the prior year's walkway (wheelbarrow way) is definitely not true with my near-saline soil infiltrated by bermuda grass.
I don't exactly understand the argument about fitting crops to spaces. I personally have a bit of a problem, but that's only because I have so many perennials. But I think anyone who has a yearly reboot (aka "hard freeze") shouldn't have any trouble figuring out how much of what they want to plant. If they need more potatoes, they'll just build a box dedicated to potatoes, or put in extra squares in a different box. I guess the author is stating the idea that you can easily expand your row garden. Which is sort of true, but there's no free lunch. If you expand the row you'll also have to expand the amount of soil that you till, water, weed, and fertilize.
The assumption that you're missing out by not rotating over the prior year's walkway (wheelbarrow way) is definitely not true with my near-saline soil infiltrated by bermuda grass.
I don't exactly understand the argument about fitting crops to spaces. I personally have a bit of a problem, but that's only because I have so many perennials. But I think anyone who has a yearly reboot (aka "hard freeze") shouldn't have any trouble figuring out how much of what they want to plant. If they need more potatoes, they'll just build a box dedicated to potatoes, or put in extra squares in a different box. I guess the author is stating the idea that you can easily expand your row garden. Which is sort of true, but there's no free lunch. If you expand the row you'll also have to expand the amount of soil that you till, water, weed, and fertilize.
markqz
Forum Moderator- Posts : 764
Join date : 2019-09-02
Location : Lower left hand corner
sanderson likes this post
Re: help refuting a raised bed critic
thank you all for you responses if it is not against rules the would like include a link
to the other forum where the debate it taking place. I defiantly need a bit of back up.
they seem think even flat bed are better in rows but even if bed are flat and
planted with Mel's mix they at same depth as raised bed they produce more than rows.
I think those I am arguing with seem to be math impaired and they are also from uk.
Mel's books have be published in uk. correct?
.
their arguments seem to be blinkered and also primitive when comes vegetable gardening.
seems you guys night owls like I am.
to the other forum where the debate it taking place. I defiantly need a bit of back up.
they seem think even flat bed are better in rows but even if bed are flat and
planted with Mel's mix they at same depth as raised bed they produce more than rows.
I think those I am arguing with seem to be math impaired and they are also from uk.
Mel's books have be published in uk. correct?
.
their arguments seem to be blinkered and also primitive when comes vegetable gardening.
seems you guys night owls like I am.
wargarden2017- Posts : 33
Join date : 2022-09-16
Location : usa
Re: help refuting a raised bed critic
markqz It's unclear what sort of comparison is being made
that is why I ask the person to post quote full of info
because there seemed to be missing information.
OhioGardener wrote:No need to refute, to each their own. If the person doesn't want to use raised beds, that is their choice. There is no mandate to use raised beds, nor is there one to use SFG techniques.
it is not matter of refuting it is a matter that they claim raise beds are inferior
and produce poorer results which definitely not true. my full opinion of them
would likely get me banned for using words not allowed on this forum.
wargarden2017- Posts : 33
Join date : 2022-09-16
Location : usa
Re: help refuting a raised bed critic
The purpose of the Forum is to support folks who want to do SFG. The purpose is not to argue with someone who does not want to try it.
This person who you are trying to argue with doesn't know what he is talking about. Drop him.
This person who you are trying to argue with doesn't know what he is talking about. Drop him.
Re: help refuting a raised bed critic
Sanderson,
I fully agree with your assessment.
The arguments presented by the raised-bed opponent are nonsensical. One cannot argue with irrationality.
I fully agree with your assessment.
The arguments presented by the raised-bed opponent are nonsensical. One cannot argue with irrationality.
sanderson likes this post

» First post, first time SFG, potato question
» what to use around raised bed
» New Raised Bed
» above ground sfg beds
» Is that another raised bed?!
» what to use around raised bed
» New Raised Bed
» above ground sfg beds
» Is that another raised bed?!
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|