Option #2
Compost (Main Yard)
Our compost is a ground down blend of leaves, brush, and other yard waste, which then is left to rot for 3-5 years time. We then screen the material for the finished product. Great for using in vegetable gardens or blending with you existing soil to add needed nutrients.

And say no to option #1 using the Herrington composted cow manure, that way my concern about persistent pesticides/herbicides from the hay, straw and feed passing through the into the cows manure since they're not an organic dairy farm.

I could also pickup a few bags of commercially packaged compost of something like a land and sea, or cow manure....