Square Foot Gardening Forum
[table bgcolor=#000000 height=275][tr][td]
SFG Vs Hydropoinics Toplef10SFG Vs Hydropoinics 1zd3ho10

Hello Guest!
Welcome to the official Square Foot Gardening Forum.
There's lots to learn here by reading as a guest. However, if you become a member (it's free, ad free and spam-free) you'll have access to our large vermiculite databases, our seed exchange spreadsheets, Mel's Mix calculator, and many more members' pictures in the Gallery. Enjoy.

SFG Vs Hydropoinics I22gcj10SFG Vs Hydropoinics 14dhcg10

[/td][/tr][/table]
Search
 
 

Display results as :
 

 


Rechercher Advanced Search

Latest topics
» Panic Buying due to Cornavirus Pandemic
by yolos Yesterday at 11:27 pm

» Saving Kale Seeds
by markqz Yesterday at 11:02 pm

» How's the Weather Where You're At?
by Scorpio Rising Yesterday at 11:02 pm

» Birds of the Garden
by Emily49 Yesterday at 8:32 pm

» SFG Journey: Memorial Day
by has55 Yesterday at 5:04 pm

» A Louisiana hello
by OhioGardener Yesterday at 4:39 pm

» What Have You Picked From Your Garden Today
by plantoid Yesterday at 1:37 pm

» N&C Midwest: May 2020
by Scorpio Rising Yesterday at 10:24 am

» Eddie Willers 1st rookie mistake, what to do?
by Kelejan Yesterday at 9:10 am

» CANADIAN REGION: What are you doing April, May, June, 2020
by Kelejan Yesterday at 8:58 am

» Almost 68, and this is a new one on me !!!!
by Kelejan Yesterday at 8:53 am

» Hello from Tavistock, Ontario, Canada
by lvanderb Yesterday at 6:47 am

» 2020 Bunny Gardening
by Scorpio Rising 5/27/2020, 6:35 pm

» Cannellini Beans
by sanderson 5/27/2020, 3:01 pm

» New from Rancho Cucamonga, CA
by Tcwilson99 5/27/2020, 1:33 pm

» Squash bugs
by Luke Allen 5/26/2020, 8:57 pm

» Mail order tomato plants
by Scorpio Rising 5/26/2020, 5:50 pm

» Spring Flowers
by OhioGardener 5/26/2020, 5:19 pm

» what do you put in the compost that other may not of thought of?
by Jazzlover 5/26/2020, 2:08 am

» Can you continuously add material to a pile that is composting?
by mollyhespra 5/25/2020, 10:08 pm

» Rogue strawberries
by mollyhespra 5/25/2020, 9:53 pm

» Cheerleaders needed, please. This is daunting.
by mollyhespra 5/25/2020, 9:30 pm

» New England, May 2020
by Scorpio Rising 5/25/2020, 9:26 pm

» Just about got enough seeds sown & seedlings transplanted
by Scorpio Rising 5/25/2020, 9:22 pm

» Sprouting - 95% success
by Emily49 5/25/2020, 2:39 pm

» Hi from Fredericton New Brunswick
by Eddie Willers 5/25/2020, 1:41 pm

» SFG top hats
by plantoid 5/24/2020, 6:08 pm

» What are you eating from your garden today?
by Hypogeiody 5/24/2020, 10:36 am

» Wood Pallets Hugelkultur Bed
by Dan in Ct 5/24/2020, 7:52 am

» NEED SOIL! Mahalo and much Aloha, San Diego Style!
by Judy McNutt 5/24/2020, 2:11 am

Google

Search SFG Forum

SFG Vs Hydropoinics

Go down

SFG Vs Hydropoinics Empty SFG Vs Hydropoinics

Post  mageice3 on 2/27/2012, 3:34 pm

After reading Mel's book (only for the third time) I decided there was an interesting correlation between ANSFG's and Simple Hydroponics gardens.

In a Hydro Garden you use an aggregate to support your plants and a nutrient solution to feed them. The aggregate of choice is coarse vermiculite mixed with peat moss for the same reasons Mel states (pg. 98). Then the nutrients are in a solution with water, and only accessible to the roots that enter the solution.

Now from this the only difference between the two is the source of nutrients (compost), however ancient systems used compost as the nutrients (at least from descriptions of the old Roman and Greek aqua-duct hydroponic systems, the soil was a deep black and made from dead plant material, sound familiar?) as well as expanded clay and peat moss. Now the expanded clay is still available but having worked with it I wouldn't recommend it, it feels like small pebbles and can be very sharp, So we use an equally absorbent material - Vermiculite.

So after much research (in both fields) its my opinion that what Mel did is rediscover ancient methods of efficient gardening, then improve on them. Take the descriptions of the hanging gardens of Babylon, each was placed on a wall (period walls would be between 2'-3' thick) and required very little maintenance or tending but produced enough food and flowers for the whole city.

Regardless of how it came to be, Mel's ANSFG is a hybrid hydroponic garden, without the air issues that plague many hydro systems (roots not getting enough air that is.) and I look forward to spending many years enjoying my gardens.

Hope to hear what you all think of this interesting insight,
James
mageice3
mageice3

Male Posts : 44
Join date : 2012-02-17
Location : Idaho Falls, ID Zone 4a

Back to top Go down

SFG Vs Hydropoinics Empty Re: SFG Vs Hydropoinics

Post  plantoid on 2/27/2012, 4:08 pm

I'm betting that a minimum of a five way compost mix will supply far more nutrients and trace elements than any hydroponic solutions does . Infact I've cheated by saying that Wink , for I was given that information some 15 years or more ago by a NewZealand government employed agri expert when we were at a seminar on growing hydroponic crops and as to why they were so tasteless even when picked ripe .
plantoid
plantoid

Male Posts : 3995
Join date : 2011-11-09
Age : 69
Location : At the west end of M4 in the UK

Back to top Go down

SFG Vs Hydropoinics Empty Re: SFG Vs Hydropoinics

Post  plantoid on 2/27/2012, 4:09 pm

@plantoid wrote:I'm betting that a minimum of a five way compost mix with worm used stuff in it will supply far more nutrients and trace elements than any current chemical factory made hydroponic solutions does .

Infact I've cheated by saying that Wink , for I was given that information some 15 years or more ago by a NewZealand government employed agri expert when we were at a seminar on growing hydroponic crops and as to why they were so tasteless even when picked ripe .
plantoid
plantoid

Male Posts : 3995
Join date : 2011-11-09
Age : 69
Location : At the west end of M4 in the UK

Back to top Go down

SFG Vs Hydropoinics Empty Re: SFG Vs Hydropoinics

Post  mageice3 on 2/27/2012, 4:54 pm

@plantoid wrote:I'm betting that a minimum of a five way compost mix will supply far more nutrients and trace elements than any hydroponic solutions does . Infact I've cheated by saying that Wink , for I was given that information some 15 years or more ago by a NewZealand government employed agri expert when we were at a seminar on growing hydroponic crops and as to why they were so tasteless even when picked ripe .

While its true compost gives better nutrients that most hydroponic fertilizers (and costs a fraction of the price), many of the newer ones do supply enough nutrients to make delicious crops (mostly from the Nightshade family, or leaf veggies.) but the application is less ensured then with Mel's Mix, and that's where I find the quality improved (even in my seedlings, and I look forward to a more complete comparison when my veggies mature.)

Tho, I would like to point the finger at one Hydro technique that I find better than whats provided in soil, is Rooting Cuttings, the mist hydroponics systems are amazing for rooting Tomato Cuttings and when rooted can be planted into the ANSFG without any problems.

James
mageice3
mageice3

Male Posts : 44
Join date : 2012-02-17
Location : Idaho Falls, ID Zone 4a

Back to top Go down

SFG Vs Hydropoinics Empty Re: SFG Vs Hydropoinics

Post  Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum